Paid Social Isn’t a Magic Wand, Here’s What Founders Get Wrong

Paid social isn’t a silver bullet — but used right, it’s one of the most powerful levers for growth.

The problem? Many founders expect it to work instantly… without putting the right pieces in place.

If you’ve tried Meta ads and felt disappointed, you’re not alone. In most cases, underperformance comes down to misaligned expectations or missing steps — not the platform itself.

Here’s what I see founders get wrong most often, and what to do instead.

1. Using organic content as ad creative

Great organic posts don’t always make great ads. Performance creative has to stop the scroll, hook early, and speak directly to a pain point — fast.

Your grid might look beautiful, but in an ad feed, it’s competing with videos, memes, and creators who know exactly how to grab attention.

The strongest ads are built for the platform: native, direct, and designed to blend into the feed while still making people stop. Think UGC, reaction hooks, and quick, benefit-led edits.

2. Testing too little, too soon

One audience, one creative, one week — then switched off. Sound familiar?

Paid social is all about structured testing. Sometimes the audience is right but the creative flops. Sometimes it’s the other way around. You need enough variations to spot what’s working and why.

A good starting point:

• Two creative styles (e.g., UGC vs founder-led)

• Warm vs cold audiences

• Hook-first vs benefit-first messaging

3. Sending people to the wrong place

Your homepage might look great, but for ad traffic, it’s rarely the best choice. It forces people to figure out where to click, which kills momentum.

Instead, send people to a focused, relevant, benefit-led page — even if it’s a simplified product page or a one-page mobile hub. The fewer decisions they have to make, the better your conversion rate will be.

4. Expecting instant results

Paid social takes time to learn what works. The early phase is about gathering data — which is often the most valuable part of the process.

Think of your initial budget as buying insight, not just sales. Those insights will let you optimise, scale, and actually make the channel profitable.

The takeaway

Paid social isn’t magic. But it can deliver powerful results if you:

• Create content specifically for ads

• Run structured tests and give them time

• Send traffic to the right place

• Treat the learning phase as an investment

If you’re unsure whether your setup is holding you back, drop me a message. I’m happy to take a look and share a few ideas.